First Time Ever Offered – Custom Built by the Original Owner in 1954
A rare opportunity to own a home that has been cherished by the same family since it was custom built in 1954. Being offered for the first time, this special property is filled with history, character, and unlimited potential.
Situated on a beautifully landscaped 100’ x 100’ park-like property in one of Farmingdale’s most desirable neighborhoods, this spacious Cape offers the perfect combination of location, lot size, and opportunity.
The home features 3 generously sized bedrooms, 2½ bathrooms, and an expansive unfinished attic that is ready to become a fourth bedroom, luxurious primary suite, home office, or additional living space. The inviting living area is highlighted by a beautiful natural stone fireplace, creating a warm and timeless focal point for family gatherings.
A significant investment has already been made in the home’s major mechanical systems, including a newer oil burner and oil storage tank, allowing the next owner to focus on making the home their own.
Outside, you’ll discover an impressive park-like backyard with mature landscaping and exceptional privacy. The oversized 100’ x 100’ lot provides ample room for outdoor entertaining, recreation, gardening, or future expansion, subject to local approvals. A paver stone driveway enhances the home’s curb appeal and complements its classic design.
This is more than just a home—it’s an opportunity to continue the legacy of a property that has been lovingly cared for by its original owner for more than 70 years.
Property Highlights
First time ever offered for sale
Custom built by the original owner in 1954
Rare 100’ × 100’ oversized park-like property
3 Bedrooms
2½ Bathrooms
Spacious unfinished attic with fourth-bedroom or primary suite potential
Beautiful natural stone fireplace
Paver stone driveway
Newer oil burner and oil storage tank
Full basement
Large attached garage
Exceptional opportunity to customize and add value
Located in one of Farmingdale’s most sought-after neighborhoods
? A rare opportunity to create your dream home on one of Farmingdale’s finest 100’ × 100’ park-like properties.
- Heating System:
- Oil, Energy Star Qualified Equipment
- Cooling System:
- No
- Basement:
- Partially Finished
- Fence:
- Chain Link
- Patio:
- Covered
- Appliances:
- Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Gas Range, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven
- Fireplaces Total:
- 1
- Garage Spaces:
- 1
- Interior Features:
- First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath
- Parking Features:
- Driveway, Garage
- Sewer:
- Public Sewer
- Utilities:
- Natural Gas Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected
- City:
- Oyster Bay
- State:
- NY
- Neighborhood:
- Farmingdale
- Street:
- Spruce
- Street Number:
- 23
- Street Suffix:
- Street
- Postal Code:
- 11735
- Floor Number:
- 0
- Longitude:
- W74° 33' 51.4''
- Latitude:
- N40° 43' 19.1''
- PostalCity:
- Farmingdale
- Architectural Style:
- Cape Cod
- Construction Materials:
- Frame
- Elementary School:
- Albany Avenue Elementary School
- High School:
- Farmingdale Senior High School
- Agent MlsId:
- 109452
- MiddleOrJunior School:
- Howitt School
- PhotosCount:
- 50
- Special Listing Conditions:
- No
- Tax Annual Amount:
- $14,695
- Water Source:
- Public
- Office MlsId:
- EMEX01
Residential - MLS# 1021728
23 Spruce Street, Oyster Bay, NY
- Property Type :
- Residential
- Property SubType :
- Single Family Residence
- Listing Type :
- For Rent
- Listing ID :
- 1021728
- Price :
- $899,000
- Rooms :
- 7
- Bedrooms :
- 3
- Bathrooms :
- 2
- Half Bathrooms :
- 1
- Bathrooms Total :
- 3
- Square Footage :
- 1,809 Sqft
- Building Area :
- 1,809 Sqft
- Lot Area :
- 0.23 Acre
- Year Built :
- 1954
- Status :
- Active
- Listing Agent :
- Mark J. Lagnese
- Listing Office :
- X Marks The Spot Home Svcs Inc



















































