The One-Eyed Horse Farm: A Turn-of-the-Century Estate Where a Tonight Show Legend Once Practiced Trumpet in the Shed…Some properties are simply for sale. This one comes with a story!!
Set on five pastoral acres along coveted Bellvale Lakes Road, The One Eyed Horse Farm pairs Victorian character with land that’s ready for horses from day one, one hour from New York City, in the Warwick Valley Central School District. Four bedrooms and two and a half baths offer space to spread out, whether as a full-time residence or a weekend retreat.
At its heart is a roughly 3,000-square-foot barn built for two lives: one side outfitted with stalls and a tack room, the other renovated into flexible creative space, office, gym, or private retreat.
Inside the house, soaring ceilings, handcrafted banisters, original wide-plank flooring, and period trim carry the weight of a home built to last. Four decorative fireplaces anchor the main living spaces, a gourmet kitchen gathers everyone in, formal rooms invite long dinners, and the primary suite offers a quiet retreat from it all.
Outside, it’s rolling acreage and open sky, the kind of land that makes mornings on the porch and evenings under the stars feel like the whole point.
And the history: for years, this property belonged to Doc Severinsen, the Tonight Show bandleader, who is said to have built the shed to practice trumpet in peace. That thread of music and creativity still runs through the place.
A rare offering, one hour from Manhattan, worlds apart. Designed to be lived in, not just owned.