Property Description

A Rare Find: Fully Renovated Cape Cod with Legal Accessory Cottage
Some properties simply check boxes. This one rewrites the list.
Old World charm collides with fresh, modern luxury in this beautifully renovated 2,048 sq. ft. Cape Cod — flooded with natural light and paired with a fully updated legal accessory cottage, all set on a gently sloping, storybook lot with unobstructed views.
The Main House — 4 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms
Sun pours into every corner of this home, illuminating the original parquet floors that anchor the living and dining rooms with warmth and character. These floors aren’t just original — they’re stunning, period-authentic, and absolutely irreplaceable.
Then there’s the kitchen. This isn’t just a renovation — it’s a statement. parquet underfoot, gleaming quartz countertops, top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances, and custom cabinetry that would make any chef do a double-take. Beautifully laid out and flooded with light, it’s the kind of space that makes cooking feel like an event.
The flow of the home is something special. Two bedrooms live comfortably on the main level, while two additional bedrooms upstairs offer flexibility for family, guests, or the home office you’ve been dreaming about. Two fully updated bathrooms serve the main house with style and function.
The Cottage — 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom with Office
Across the yard sits the cottage, and calling it an “accessory” almost undersells it. Fully renovated, with its own attached garage, this one-bedroom, one-bath retreat is ready for whatever chapter you write next — multi-generational living, a private guest escape, or a high-demand Airbnb. Step outside onto the substantial deck, perfectly positioned to take in the views and unwind. Every finish matches the quality of the main house. No corners cut here.
The Grounds & Views
The lot itself is a gentle, rolling canvas. Mature plantings frame the property with natural beauty, while unobstructed views stretch out before you — no crowding, no overlooking neighbors, just open space and sky. There are countless spots to create outdoor living areas: a bistro set under the trees, a dining table on the lawn, lounge chairs catching the afternoon sun. The possibilities are already there, waiting.
The Bottom Line
Both buildings have been taken down to the studs in spirit — substantial, top-to-bottom renovations that marry timeless Cape Cod character with modern systems, modern finishes, and modern comfort. It’s rare. It’s turnkey. It’s a genuine gem.

Features
Heating System:
Electric
Cooling System:
No
Basement:
Full, Unfinished
Appliances:
Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Gas Range
Flooring:
Hardwood, Ceramic Tile, Wood
Garage Spaces:
2
Interior Features:
Eat-in Kitchen, Master Downstairs, Open Kitchen, Open Floorplan, Chefs Kitchen, Kitchen Island, Original Details, Washer/dryer Hookup, First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Quartz/quartzite Counters, Built-in Features, Recessed Lighting, Crown Molding
Laundry Features:
Gas Dryer Hookup, Laundry Room, Washer Hookup
Parking Features:
Driveway, Garage, Private, Common
Sewer:
Septic Tank
Utilities:
Trash Collection Private, Water Connected, Electricity Connected
Address Map
City:
Fallsburg
State:
NY
Street:
Benton Hollow
Street Number:
810
Street Suffix:
Road
Postal Code:
12788
Floor Number:
0
Longitude:
W75° 23' 26.6''
Latitude:
N41° 48' 15.2''
PostalCity:
Woodbourne
Additional Information
Architectural Style:
Carriage House, Cape Cod, Includes Legal Accessory Apartment
Construction Materials:
Clapboard
Elementary School:
Tri-Valley Elementary School
High School:
Tri-Valley Secondary School
Levels:
Two
Agent MlsId:
KEY55557
MiddleOrJunior School:
Tri-Valley Secondary School
PhotosCount:
50
Special Listing Conditions:
No
Tax Annual Amount:
$7,353
Water Source:
Well
Office MlsId:
KEYKWHV03

Residential - MLS# KEY1018680

810 Benton Hollow Road, Fallsburg, NY

6 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
2,048 Sqft
$499,400
Listing ID #KEY1018680
Basic Details
Property Type :
Residential
Property SubType :
Single Family Residence
Listing Type :
For Rent
Listing ID :
KEY1018680
Price :
$499,400
Rooms :
10
Bedrooms :
6
Bathrooms :
3
Bathrooms Total :
3
Square Footage :
2,048 Sqft
Building Area :
2,048 Sqft
Lot Area :
1 Acre
Year Built :
1984
Status :
Active
Listing Agent :
Dominique Jenkins
Listing Office :
KW Hudson Valley United
Agent info
Coldwell Banker American Homes
284 West Park Ave
Contact Agent
Walkscore