Property Description

Potential for Three Separate Floors of Living | Exceptional Multi-Generational Opportunity with Rare Investment Potential

Welcome to one of the Village of Farmingdale’s most unique opportunities — an extraordinarily rare oversized 9-bedroom high ranch offering the highly sought-after potential for three separate floors of living, making this an exceptional opportunity for mother-daughter living, large extended families, multi-generational households, or the savvy buy-and-hold investor seeking long-term upside and flexibility.

This expansive residence offers an incredibly rare combination of size, versatility, and future potential with three full levels of living space, highlighted by a massive fully finished basement featuring high ceilings, modern conveniences, and its own private outside entrance, creating endless possibilities for separate living quarters, private guest space, recreation areas, home office use, or exceptional long-term value creation.

Whether accommodating aging parents, adult children remaining close to home, extended family seeking privacy, or an investor recognizing the rarity of a property with this level of flexibility, this home presents options that simply do not exist in today’s marketplace.

Perfectly positioned in one of Farmingdale’s most desirable locations, the property sits directly between the highly regarded elementary school and high school while remaining just moments from the vibrant Farmingdale Main Street district, the LIRR station, exceptional restaurants, shopping, nightlife, fresh markets, and the countless conveniences that make this community so highly sought after.

Just a short distance away sits the incredible Allen Park sports and entertainment complex, a true centerpiece of community life offering recreation, athletic facilities, and year-round activities for all ages.

Situated on a quiet no-through street, the exterior offers one of the property’s most unique advantages with parking capacity for up to 16 vehicles, featuring a rare two-wide, two-deep driveway configuration ideal for large families, multiple households, entertaining, or those simply valuing exceptional convenience. A covered rear porch and expansive gathering areas create the perfect setting for holidays, celebrations, family gatherings, and unforgettable moments shared for generations.

The award-winning school district is celebrated not only for exceptional academics but also for championship-level athletics beginning at the tee-ball level and continuing through highly competitive varsity programs, alongside nationally respected robotics programs, debate teams, arts education, and enrichment opportunities for students of every interest and passion.

Nearby lifestyle amenities include the Farmingdale LIRR Station, world-renowned Bethpage State Park featuring championship golf courses, polo fields, bike trails, playgrounds, soccer fields, picnic areas, sledding hills, cross-country skiing, houses of worship, year-round dining, shopping, entertainment, and countless community events that continue to make Farmingdale one of Long Island’s most desirable places to call home.

Properties offering this level of square footage, parking capacity, layout flexibility, and future upside rarely come to market.

Whether purchasing for immediate multi-generational living or securing a long-term asset with extraordinary versatility and lasting value, this is truly a one-of-a-kind opportunity built to serve both today’s needs and tomorrow’s possibilities.

There is room here for everyone — and memories still waiting to be made.

Rarely available. Impossible to duplicate.

Welcome home.

Features
Heating System:
Oil, Hot Air
Cooling System:
Wall/window Unit(s)
Basement:
Finished, Full
View:
Open
Fence:
Back Yard, Chain Link, Vinyl
Patio:
Patio, Covered
Appliances:
Dishwasher, Cooktop, Electric Oven, Gas Oven
Exterior Features:
Awning(s)
Fireplace Features:
Living Room
Flooring:
Hardwood, Ceramic Tile, Combination
Interior Features:
First Floor Bedroom, Ceiling Fan(s), First Floor Full Bath
Laundry Features:
In Hall, Laundry Room
Lot Features:
Near Public Transit, Level, Cleared, Garden, Near Shops, Near School, Back Yard, Landscaped, Front Yard, Near Golf Course
Parking Features:
On Street, Driveway
Sewer:
Public Sewer
Utilities:
Trash Collection Public, Cable Connected, Water Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected
Address Map
City:
Oyster Bay
State:
NY
Neighborhood:
Farmingdale
Street:
3rd
Street Number:
23
Street Suffix:
Avenue
Postal Code:
11735
Floor Number:
0
Longitude:
W74° 33' 9.4''
Latitude:
N40° 42' 50.6''
Direction Faces:
South
Directions:
GPS
PostalCity:
Farmingdale
Additional Information
Architectural Style:
Hi Ranch
Construction Materials:
Brick, Vinyl Siding
Elementary School:
Woodward Parkway Elementary School
High School:
Farmingdale Senior High School
Levels:
Three Or More
Agent MlsId:
166262
MiddleOrJunior School:
Howitt School
PhotosCount:
33
Special Listing Conditions:
No
Tax Annual Amount:
$1,695,830
Water Source:
Public
Office MlsId:
HMSM02

Residential - MLS# 1009999

23 3rd Avenue, Oyster Bay, NY

9 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
2,339 Sqft
$1,124,000
Listing ID #1009999
Basic Details
Property Type :
Residential
Property SubType :
Single Family Residence
Listing Type :
For Rent
Listing ID :
1009999
Price :
$1,124,000
Rooms :
15
Bedrooms :
9
Bathrooms :
3
Bathrooms Total :
3
Square Footage :
2,339 Sqft
Building Area :
3,456 Sqft
Lot Area :
0.16 Acre
Lot Dimensions :
70 x 100
Year Built :
1971
Status :
Active
Listing Agent :
Joseph Vennera
Listing Office :
HomeSmart Premier Living Rlty
Agent info
Coldwell Banker American Homes
284 West Park Ave
Contact Agent
Walkscore